Asparagus haakesque

June 9, 2007 at 3:24 AM (asparagus, dishes by cuisine, dishes by main ingredient, India, Kashmir, various greens, vegetables/ fruits)

    Total blasphemy! I know it. Ask me if I care. Something strange happens after you eat the Kashmiri dish known as haak for the first time. It changes your brain chemistry and makes you want more! The sad, dejected, longing look that appears on your face when the last traces are devoured in a bowl with rice, its green, vitamin-rich gravy soaking into the fluffy grains, is totally pre-conceived by those wily, saunf-and-saunth-throwing hooligans. I surrender… but this is my revenge!

    Asparagus is in season now in this neck of the woods. I’m ill of the Thai green curry that resists spoiling, I can’t take another round of daalitoy at the moment (or can I?), and although I have val sitting in soaking-water, I want some green stuff now! Some days, I feel like Veruca Salt…

    So, green stuff it is! Anita of A Mad Tea Party sent me a recipe for haak, which is made of a special green very similar to collard greens- same species, different variety. There is also a green used by the Chinese and Thai which is yet another similar variety -and can also be used for successful haak-making. It is called kai lan or Chinese broccoli. All are cruciferous vegetables(of the plant family cruciferae, now known as brassicaceae), and the botanical genus-and-species name of all three is brassica oleracea…this single species has been cultivated as well into cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, brussel sprouts, kohlrabi and kale, as well as the aforementioned greens! So, as you can see, despite being descended long ago from a single plant, there is some difference between them… It took some doing to sort all of this out; I hope we have it straight.

    Anita- a regal, proud, and oftentimes giddy Kashmiri Pandit- insists that mustard oil be used for this dish. I implore you to seek it out in Indian shops either under the English name or as sarson ka tel, as it is known in Hindi. Quite pungent when raw, but sweet and mellow upon heating, this is an essential flavour in this dish that, if you were to replace it with another oil and serve it to a weathered haak-eater, would bring scoffs and jeers while your back was turned, but its inclusion will undoubtedly bring them back to your table.

    While a pressure-cooker is often used for preparing haak (it saves both time and energy, so why not? Anita pressure-cooks haak for exactly 5 minutes, then immediately releases the pressure- a secret step to keeping the greens green), I cooked this blasphemous version (do I hear noses turning upward?) the old-fashioned, open-kettle way with slow simmering, because I wasn’t sure of the timing and didn’t want to overcook my beloved asparagus (which incidentally, is not anywhere near a close relative of brassica oleracea). Hing/asafoetida is an optional ingredient that non-Kashmiri Madhur Jaffrey uses, but Anita doesn’t. I leave its use up to you.

    One more thing: after heating the oil- 2t to 1/2 C- health-level to swoon-level (and sizzling a good pinch of hing), Mrs. Jaffrey adds the greens (1 3/4 lb), covers the pot for 10 seconds, then adds the salt and stir-fries for a minute before adding the water(3 1/2 C) and a few chiles- both green and red. Anita adds the water(2 C) directly to the smoking oil, brings to a boil and adds a pinch of sodium bicarbonate (retains the green colour, but I hear it annihilates a few vitamins), then she adds the greens(1 1/2 lb), cooks them just until they wilt, adds both green and red chiles and some salt, and then … both are in agreement- continuing with the braising until tender. Because Madhur uses a bit more water than Anita, any excess must be boiled off rapidly when the vegetable is tender to reduce it to about 3/4 C or so… Anita’s method is a bit more stream-lined, as it has exactly the right amount of liquid at the end, but then again, she uses a pressure-cooker.

    Serve with yoghurt and steamed rice, a flush and a gush and now you’re hooked- er… haaked– too! There is no more to say.

    Oh, yes there is!…. If you decide to try the rebel asparagus version, it cooks in 15 minutes at a simmer. Quite done in fact. Lift it out of the pan and place it somewhere gently, then reduce the liquid and re-unite them. Total yum…

Here is some purple asparagus for fun and anti-mango measures………….en guarde you mango-braggarts!:


  1. Anita said,

    😀 I read ‘asparagus’ in the title and knew – revenge!! These from your garden? Wow!
    Maybe I will have to take out some of that hard earned money and get myself some overpriced asparagus, and try the haakesque version! Hey why not? I do a <i>sotchal</i> (another Kashmiri green) with broccoli; you are very much within your rights to do a <em>haak</em>; on asparagus!
    I wish more of my family would wax half as eloquent on haak as you do! (I hope TH reads this). Perfect combo with dahi and steamed rice. And with the mustard oil: 10/10!
    But whose recipe did you follow – Mrs J or mine? :one eyebrow raised:

    Ah…that is the question! My lips are sealed, lest by chance and association through Kamla, then you, she were to read it; I couldn’t possibly offend her…or you!
    These are from one of several “pick-your-own” farms outside of the city…This particular farm also grows strawberries (any day now) and pumpkins! They own some very choice farm-land that gently slopes down a hill… very rich soil, and hence, well-known for beautiful crops.

  2. Anita said,

    Notice – not a word on mangoes. 😉
    on what? 🙂

  3. elaichietcetera said,

    There is a big problem with the html coding right now…looks like the WordPress developers have a little chore on monday….commentators, please forgive the code-exposure until then…

  4. Cynthia said,

    I love coming to this place. The war of words and war of recipes, techniques and ingredients makes me glad to be just an onlooker 😀

    Don’t be so sure…no-one is safe! 🙂

  5. Monjji Haak…at long last « A Mad Tea Party said,

    […] and shared my recipe. Pel tried it first with kai-lan and was very pleased. Then he presented his haakesque asparagus (and laid bare all the secret tricks I have for retaining the colour of my greens) – some sort of […]

  6. Haak Time - It’s The Most Wonderful Time of the Year « A Mad Tea Party said,

    […] which I did too, the time I lived in the US – an excellent substitute. Then Pel cooked his asparagus-haakesque. And finally Manisha presented her super version with dandelion greens. There was some discussion […]

    Aw….tansh Anitalu!

  7. Gogji-Nadir (Turnips with Lotus Root) « A Mad Tea Party said,

    […] we have done a great job of keeping away from the prying eyes of outsiders, barring a few leaks now and then.  It is likely that gogji-nadir might also manage to stay under wraps despite my tell-all […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: